Student work from ESL students at City College of San Francisco's Chinatown Campus.
Thursday, May 13, 2010
Immigration Debate
View the video above. You will hear two California governor candidates debating about illegal immigration. They discuss Arizona's new immigration law and the idea of amnesty. Listen and then type your comment below.
i don't in favor of the illegal immigration. But i think it is unnecessary to set up a immigration law like Arizona.everyone will be asked for ID though you are legal immigration.the Mexican and Chinese or other people who are not native American will likely to be asked for ID.So it is no good.
I think that illegal immigration is a big problem, how to handle it is another... I agree with Mr. Poizner, that when you want to stop illegal immigration, you need to take hard steps. It won't stop when people still feel like they have a chance of living here without being here legally.
I think the man is right , although people came here illegal ,after working a long time ,paying a lot of tax ,having a family in this country ,they should have citizenship .
I think both candidates they both have their right points. But considering the human right,those illegal immigrants are hard working and not do anything to anybody.they deserve have a pathway to citizenship.
I think the Arizona immigration law is reasonable. Since the federal government doesn't take measure to solve the illegal immigration, the local government has to do something to take care of it.
I think illegal immigration is a big problem if the government not to do something about it. It's will be more and more serious.so the government must control it.But hard to stop it.The government can check ID or green card when it necessary.
I think since the federal law applied for the illegal immigration they have to be deported or to be leaving at period of time .I am very concern about Arizona state law .
This is a a safe place for my ESL students to publish, share, and enjoy each others' writing and projects. Although most of the writing has gone through editing stages, it is authentic student writing, not teacher-edited; understandably, there will be errors.
Please enjoy!
Denise Maduli-Williams, ESL Instructor City College of San Francisco Chinatown Campus dmaduli@ccsf.edu
13 comments:
I agree with steve poizner
shirley
i don't in favor of the illegal immigration. But i think it is unnecessary to set up a immigration law like Arizona.everyone will be asked for ID though you are legal immigration.the Mexican and Chinese or other people who are not native American will likely to be asked for ID.So it is no good.
jack
I think that illegal immigration is a big problem, how to handle it is another...
I agree with Mr. Poizner, that when you want to stop illegal immigration, you need to take hard steps.
It won't stop when people still feel like they have a chance of living here without being here legally.
Nicole
I think the man is right , although people came here illegal ,after working a long time ,paying a lot of tax ,having a family in this country ,they should have citizenship .
Fiona
I agree with STEVE POIZNER,because the law can protects illegal immigrant.
I think both candidates they both have their right points. But considering the human right,those illegal immigrants are hard working and not do anything to anybody.they deserve have a pathway to citizenship.
I think the Arizona immigration law is reasonable. Since the federal government doesn't take measure to solve the illegal immigration, the local government has to do something to take care of it.
Monie Zheng
I agree with the man because everyone have to wait a long time to come here.
I think illegal immigration is a big problem if the government not to do something about it. It's will be more and more serious.so the government must control it.But hard to stop it.The government can check ID or green card when it necessary.
I think I agree with MegWhitman. Because amnesty can make social having big problem.
I think since the federal law applied for the illegal immigration they have to be deported or to be leaving at period of time .I am very concern about Arizona state law .
In fact, it's hard to decide what we should do with them. Illegal immigration is a big problem. They caused some crimes and made the city dangerous.
Coco
I think Arizona's immigrant law is doing the way,because the illegal immigrant people invade and occupy the jobs education medical etc.
Edwardwong
May 17,2010
Post a Comment